Sleepy Sheep

The Saffron Comfort Deep vs Comfort Ortho Firm: which is better?

Quick answer

The The Saffron Comfort Deep and Comfort Ortho Firm score almost the same overall (8.5 vs 8.4), so the choice comes down to feel, firmness and budget.

Both tested and scored by Alexander Bowman. Scores use the same criteria for every mattress.

The Saffron Comfort Deep mattress

The Foam People

The Saffron Comfort Deep

8.5/10 · Memory foam · Medium

£168£198

Comfort Ortho Firm mattress

The Foam People

Comfort Ortho Firm

8.4/10 · Memory foam · Firm

£171£190

Side by side

FeatureThe Saffron Comfort DeepComfort Ortho Firm
Overall score8.5/108.4/10
Support8.38.6
Comfort8.57.9
Value8.68.7
Price£168£171
TypeMemory foamMemory foam
FirmnessMediumFirm
Depth23 cm20 cm
Home trial--
Warranty5 years5 years

Prices change often; confirm on the retailer's site. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links. It never affects our scores.

Choose the The Saffron Comfort Deep if…

  • You want to spend less: it's £3 cheaper at £168.
  • Comfort matters most: it scores 8.5 vs 7.9.
  • You want a softer bed (medium), e.g. as a side sleeper.

What we like

  • 23cm depth makes it viable as a main bed, unlike the shallower Core range
  • Balanced 8.3 support / 8.5 comfort scores – no obvious weakness
  • Deep quilted cover adds a plusher surface feel

What could be better

  • No cooling technology – it sleeps warm like most all-foam builds
  • No home trial

Choose the Comfort Ortho Firm if…

  • You want a firmer bed (firm), e.g. for back or front sleeping.

What we like

  • Support score of 8.6 at £171 – outstanding for the money
  • Reflex foam gives genuine orthopaedic-grade firmness, not marketing firmness
  • Removable, washable zip cover is rare at this price

What could be better

  • Comfort score of 7.9 – it is firm, and side sleepers will feel it
  • No home trial, which matters more on a firm mattress

The Saffron Comfort Deep vs Comfort Ortho Firm: FAQs

Which is better, the The Saffron Comfort Deep or the Comfort Ortho Firm?

The The Saffron Comfort Deep and Comfort Ortho Firm score almost the same overall (8.5 vs 8.4), so the choice comes down to feel, firmness and budget.

Which is firmer, the The Saffron Comfort Deep or the Comfort Ortho Firm?

The Comfort Ortho Firm is firmer (firm), while the The Saffron Comfort Deep is medium.

Which is better value?

The Comfort Ortho Firm scores higher for value (8.7/10), at £171.