Sleepy Sheep

Arthur Sleep King Arthur 2000 vs Emma NextGen Premium Plus: which is better?

Quick answer

The Emma NextGen Premium Plus scores higher overall (8.9 vs 8.6). The Arthur Sleep King Arthur 2000 is £114 cheaper.

Both tested and scored by Alexander Bowman. Scores use the same criteria for every mattress.

Arthur Sleep King Arthur 2000 mattress

Arthur Sleep

Arthur Sleep King Arthur 2000

8.6/10 · Hybrid · Medium-firm

£565

Emma NextGen Premium Plus mattress

Emma

Emma NextGen Premium Plus

8.9/10 · Memory foam · Medium

£679

Side by side

FeatureArthur Sleep King Arthur 2000Emma NextGen Premium Plus
Overall score8.6/108.9/10
Support8.69.0
Comfort8.79.1
Value8.58.6
Price£565£679
TypeHybridMemory foam
FirmnessMedium-firmMedium
Depth34 cm27 cm
Home trial60 nights200 nights
Warranty10 years10 years

Prices change often; confirm on the retailer's site. We may earn a commission if you buy through our links. It never affects our scores.

Choose the Arthur Sleep King Arthur 2000 if…

  • You want to spend less: it's £114 cheaper at £565.
  • You want a firmer bed (medium-firm), e.g. for back or front sleeping.
  • You prefer a springy, more responsive feel that sleeps cooler than all-foam.

What we like

  • 34cm deep with a box pillow top, among the deepest mattresses we review
  • Medium-firm feel that suits back, side and combination sleepers
  • 10-year warranty, stated consistently on the page

What could be better

  • The 60-night trial is an exchange for a £50 fee, and needs a protector bought with the mattress
  • 34cm needs extra-deep fitted sheets and sits high on a tall bed frame

Choose the Emma NextGen Premium Plus if…

  • Support matters most: it scores 9.0 vs 8.6.
  • Comfort matters most: it scores 9.1 vs 8.7.
  • You want a softer bed (medium), e.g. as a side sleeper.
  • You prefer close-contouring pressure relief and very little motion transfer for couples.
  • You want the longer home trial (200 nights).

What we like

  • Support score of 9.0 without springs, rare for an all-foam mattress
  • Graphite-infused foam genuinely helps with heat for a foam build
  • Excellent motion isolation, our Best for Couples pick in the Emma range

What could be better

  • £679 is hybrid money for an all-foam mattress
  • Edge support cannot match the sprung Original Pro at £20 more

Arthur Sleep King Arthur 2000 vs Emma NextGen Premium Plus: FAQs

Which is better, the Arthur Sleep King Arthur 2000 or the Emma NextGen Premium Plus?

The Emma NextGen Premium Plus scores higher overall (8.9 vs 8.6). The Arthur Sleep King Arthur 2000 is £114 cheaper.

Which is firmer, the Arthur Sleep King Arthur 2000 or the Emma NextGen Premium Plus?

The Arthur Sleep King Arthur 2000 is firmer (medium-firm), while the Emma NextGen Premium Plus is medium.

Which is better value?

The Emma NextGen Premium Plus scores higher for value (8.6/10), at £679.

Which has the longer trial?

The Emma NextGen Premium Plus (200 nights, vs 60).